Can I set different icons to show for every product?

I want to show different trust icons per product. For example: for the Hip Shoes product page, I want to show JCB, Paypal, and VISA.

Meanwhile, on the Awesome Sneakers product page, I want to put in American Express, Diners Club, and MasterCard. Is this possible?

Unfortunately, this is not possible. When adding trust icons, this will apply to all products in the entire store. There is no setting within the app that will allow you to specify icons on a per-product basis.